Why economic is a science

Economics, often seen as a complex interplay of financial trends and market behaviours, is frequently debated in its classification as a science. To some, it appears as a collection of abstract theories far removed from the ‘hard’ sciences like physics and chemistry, which boast clear, testable hypotheses and predictable results. However, by examining its foundations, methodologies, and the way it employs empirical data, we can assert that economics is indeed a science. This article aims to unfold the scientific layers of economics, challenging the traditional view and highlighting its empirical underpinnings.

The Scientific Foundations of Economics

Economics as a Social Science

At its core, economics is a social science concerned with the production, distribution, and consumption of goods and services. It studies how individuals, businesses, and governments make decisions on allocating resources that are scarce and have many alternative uses. The primary distinction between economics and natural sciences lies in its focus on human behaviour and societal structures rather than physical phenomena.

Economics is divided into two major areas:

• Macroeconomics deals with whole economies, examining aggregate phenomena such as GDP growth rates, inflation, and unemployment.
• Microeconomics focuses on individual agents within the economy, like households and firms, and how they respond to changes in prices or economic policies.

Economic Models and Predictive Power

Economists use models to abstract and simplify the complex realities of economic systems. These models are not physical representations but mathematical ones, built to predict outcomes based on certain assumptions. For instance, the supply and demand model predicts how changes in price affect the quantity of goods sold and bought.

Though these models may lack the experimental predictability of physics, they provide valuable insights and are constantly refined as new data becomes available. A famous example is the predictive model used by the Bank of England for inflation rates, which has undergone numerous revisions to enhance its accuracy and reliability.

Economic Experiments and Empirical Data

Contrary to popular belief, economics extensively uses empirical data to validate theories. The rise of behavioural economics, pioneered by economists such as Daniel Kahneman and Amos Tversky, introduced experiments into economics, similar to methods used in psychology. These experiments often involve real participants making decisions in controlled environments, providing economists data that challenge or support existing theories.

An illustrative example is the ‘ultimatum game’, an experiment where two participants decide how to divide a sum of money. The results consistently show that people favour fair divisions, contradicting the traditional economic assumption that individuals are purely self-interested.

Comparing Economics with Natural Sciences

While economics may not always offer the experimental clarity of natural sciences, it shares many of their characteristics:

• Use of empirical data: Just as biologists use data to understand animal behaviours, economists use data to track economic trends and test hypotheses.
• Mathematical modelling: Similar to physics, economics makes extensive use of mathematical models to describe and predict behaviours.
• Predictive power: Although economic predictions can be complex due to human factors, they are often remarkably accurate at forecasting general trends, much like weather predictions in meteorology.

Interdisciplinary Approaches and Econophysics

Econophysics, an emerging field that applies theories and methods from physics to economic problems, exemplifies how economics intersects with other scientific disciplines. By analysing patterns within financial markets and modelling economic dynamics using physical laws, econophysicists contribute to a deeper understanding of economic phenomena.

This integration highlights the scientific flexibility and depth of economics, challenging the notion that it does not adhere to the scientific method. One notable contribution from econophysics is the modelling of stock market crashes as critical phenomena, analogous to physical systems at critical points.

Conclusion

Economics, with its rigorous models, empirical analysis, and predictive capabilities, rightfully earns its place among the sciences. It applies a scientific method to social phenomena, seeking to understand and predict human behaviour in economic contexts. By employing both qualitative and quantitative tools, economics not only enhances our understanding of how societies allocate resources but also enriches the broader field of social science research.

FAQs